Tobacco and E-Cigarette Products (Enforcement) Amendment Bill

The Hon. N.P. CLANCY (Elder—Minister for Small and Family Business, Minister for Multicultural Affairs) (12:21): I rise today in support of the Tobacco and E-Cigarette Products (Enforcement) Amendment Bill, which seeks to amend the Tobacco and E-Cigarette Products Act 1997 and to make related amendments to the Retail and Commercial Leases Act 1995.

In my first speech in this place, which feels like a long time ago, I made a promise to Miss T that I would always work to make our state better for her, her generation and those who come after. The commitment we made as a Labor opposition, prior to coming to government in 2022, was to govern not just for the next four years but for the next generation—for the future. Central to our commitment to T and her peers is our understanding that, to improve the lives of South Australians tomorrow, we need to be investing in education and preventative health care today.

Smoking tobacco remains one of the leading preventable causes of disease and death in Australia. We know tobacco smoke contains more than 70 chemicals that cause cancer and we know around two in every three people who smoke are likely to die from a smoking-related illness. If the human toll is not enough for you, smoking is costing the South Australian economy an estimated $2.3 billion each and every year. Illicit tobacco makes all of that worse.

South Australians purchasing illicit tobacco have no way of knowing what they are actually buying. The University of Auckland recently found that illicit tobacco contained up to 60 per cent more of the cancer-causing heavy metal cadmium than what is found in legal products. Researchers also found unusual levels of tin, lead, indium, caesium and even, shockingly, uranium.

Illicit tobacco is also cheap and can be easier to get a hold of, particularly for younger South Australians. While most available data has smoking rates coming down, the Australian Bureau of Statistics wastewater analysis has total tobacco consumption increasing 30 per cent between 2020 and 2025. We can and we must do more to ensure the gains we have made in reducing smoking rates are not wound back by the illicit tobacco trade.

The bill before us today is just one in a toolbox of many approaches to tackle this issue: getting smokes out of our kids' hands and criminal activity off our streets. Illicit tobacco is a problem for public health, a problem for South Australia Police and law enforcement, and a problem for South Australian small business owners and operators.

Many in this place will and have spoken about the health justification for this bill—and rightfully so—but I also want to talk about why this bill is important for the other side of the counter as well. I am talking about the South Australians who run our cafes, the hairdressers, Pilates studios, craft stores and bakeries, the pharmacists, and independent servos. I am talking about the South Australians who take a risk, invest their capital in a project to give back to their communities and whose hard work is being threatened and too often destroyed by illicit tobacco.

Illicit tobacco is huge, making up an estimated 55 per cent of our national tobacco market and 97 per cent of the e-cigarette market. When that much dirty money is at stake, you can count on organised crime to be fighting over it. Too often, it is innocent local residents and legitimate businesses getting caught in the middle. We have all seen the firebombings on our TV or phone screens: years of hard work, tens of thousands of dollars in stock and supplies being destroyed overnight, staff out of work, and customers too nervous to come back.

I have seen it in my own electorate, where owners of popular small businesses are calling my office regularly out of fear that reporting criminal activity and abusive behaviour to police will make them the next target. No business, worker or customer should be subjected to this treatment or this fear just because of where they work or shop. Even businesses not directly impacted by the trade are reporting higher insurance premiums, and some cannot get cover at all. The bill before us today is trying to change that.

The bill before us today will see South Australia continue to lead the nation in our crackdown on the illicit tobacco trade, with the toughest penalties of any state or territory. Should this reform be supported, illicit tobacco dealers will face jail time of up to 17 years. South Australia will also have the joint highest financial penalties in the nation for the supply and possession of large commercial quantities of illicit tobacco products, from up to $6.6 million to up to $21 million, which is more than 10 times higher than the penalties in many other jurisdictions.

In addition, expiations for offences related to the supply and possession of commercial quantities of illicit products will be expanded and will reach up to $175,000. These are penalties that actually fit the crime. Last year in this place, I spoke about an illegal tobacconist on South Road in my electorate, whose product was seized and store closed after my office forwarded a complaint from a concerned local resident to SA Police. The owners were fined just $3,000, a cost of doing business for organised crime. The increased fines in this bill go much further in being a genuine deterrent, far more than $3,000.

We know that fines are not enough; we need to, and we will, go directly after their business model. This bill proposes giving the Illicit Tobacco Taskforce within Consumer and Business Services the power to issue medium-term closure orders of 130 days, the longest in the nation. This is in addition to the short-term and interim closure orders already being employed, with 12-month closure orders remaining an instrument of the Magistrates Court.

The new compromised goods provision also enables authorised officers to seize all tobacco and e-cigarette products found during an inspection if any other breaches are found, regardless of whether or not the products are illegal. Because this trade runs on cash, ATMs will be banned from any retailer caught selling or supplying prohibited products or selling tobacco without a licence.

This bill is also about protecting our communities. Importantly, when assessing a tobacco store licence application, the Minister for Consumer and Business Affairs will be able to consider how close it is to schools, community centres and other tobacco stores. The new licensing controls will help our local precincts, too. Stopping tobacco stores from clustering together leaves room for the mix of businesses that make a main street the heart of a community.

Let me be very clear about who this bill is aimed at: it is aimed at the criminals who use a shopfront as cover. It is about protecting the innocent business owners who just want to get on with their work without the threat and inconvenience of operating near an illegal enterprise.

For landlords, many of whom are small business people and local investors themselves, this bill is balanced. Right now, a landlord can only end a lease when a long-term closure order is in place. Under this bill, they will be able to end a lease under any closure order: short, medium or long term. Landlords who take reasonable steps, such as reporting the conduct to an authorised officer, are doing exactly what we ask of them, but those who knowingly let their premises be used for this trade will face fines of up to $350,000 and, for repeat offences, up to one year in prison.

Criminals might be getting better, but so are we. Those behind illicit tobacco are organised, but so are we. This bill makes sure that the law keeps up with them. I want to finish by thanking every small and family business owner in Elder and right across our state who does the right thing. You start early, you finish late and you look after your community. You should not have to trade next door to criminals and you should not have to fear them. The Malinauskas Labor government has your back. Illicit tobacco is not welcome in our state. I commend the bill to the house.

Previous
Previous

Supporting Whyalla’s small businesses through the blast furnace closure

Next
Next

Education and Children’s Services (Miscellaneous) Amendment Bill